1996-12-02 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

207 crime problem in Charlottesville. Mr. Toscano said that curfews in other localities have had an impact. Mr. Toscano said the review and evaluation process of a curfew will be very important. Mr. Toscano said he feels the cun-ent ordinance is too overbroad and far-reaching and he would prefer to lower the age to under 17 and change the time to 12:00 midnight on weekdays and 1:00 a.m. on Fridays and Saturdays. Mr. Toscano said the proposed ordinance contains a lot of flexibility and these changes would increase that flexibility. Mr. Toscano made a motion to approve the curfew ordinance, adding the purpose clause, lowering the age to under 17, and changing the times to 12:00 midnight on weekdays and 1:00 a.m~ on weekends, and including a provision that requires that the ordinance be reviewed and evaluated one year after the initial date of enforcement. Mr. Toscano added that data should be collected to determine the effect of the ordinance and if there is a continued need for it. Ms. Daugherty seconded the motion. Ms. Daugherty said she supports Mr. Toscano's changes which makes the curfew less restrictive and addresses concerns raised by citizens. Ms. Daugherty said that the need for a curfew has been raised repeatedly in the last few years by neighborhoods. Mr. Cox said he remains unconvinced of the need for the curfew and is concerned that the ordinance will give residents a false sense of security and will raise expectations that juvenile crime, especially in the area of drugs, will reduce. Mr. Cox said there is no way to guarantee equitable enforcement of the law, noting that it is not the intent of the curfew to only enforce it in those neighborhoods asking for it. Mr. Cox said he cannot support the concept or the amended ordinance, and said Council could decide not to act and wait for further data. Ms. Richards said she is still divided on the issue, though she understands that the curfew is something neighborhoods have requested: Ms. Richards said she would like to give the neighborhoods something, but is not convinced about the curfew. Ms. Richards said the rationale for reducing the age does not seem to be supported by data. Ms. Richards noted that many parents have given their children permission to be out late and there is no general community standard of the appropriate time for youths to be out. Ms. Richards expressed concern about the enforcement of the curfew, and has concluded that the curfew will only be enforced in certain areas. Ms. Richards said she could potentially support a curfew if it applied to youths under age 16. Ms. Slaughter said that is the third time since she has been on Council that the issue of a curfew has been brought up. Ms. Slaughter said the curfew will give the police a tool and the neighborhoods are aware of that. Ms. Slaughter said she is concerned with young people wandering the streets late at night and if the curfew can prevent children from being involved in crime or being the victim of crime it will be worth it. Ms. Slaughter said she feels Council needs to look at what is appropriate for this community. Mrl Toscano suggested that the City Manager and Police Chief recommend parameters of a study of the curfew and reasonable data to collect and include as a part of the review of the ordinance. Ms. Richards recommended that a public hearing be part of the one year review. The ordinance entitled "AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REORDAIN SECTION 17-7 OF CHAPTER 17 OF THE CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY CODE, 1990, AS AMENDED, RELATING TO A GENERAL CURFEW FOR MINORS" was offered and carried over to the next meeting for consideration. RESOLUTION: MCI FRANCHISE RENEWAL Mr. O'Connell explained that MCI has taken over SoutherNet's franchise and the resolution will grant a temporary one-year extension of the franchise to allow a study by the Virginia Municipal League before granting a five-year franchise.