2001-06-04 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

108 Mr. Richard Diamond, owner of a business at 108 2nd Street, S.W., agreed with Mr. Dupont that notice of the public hearing was inadequate. Mr. Diamond said there is talk about boycotting the downtown mall because people are upset about this. He said that the proposed noise levels are too low and will cut off people' s ability to express themselves through music. Mr. Diamond said the ordinance is outrageous and an affront and the study was flawed. Mr. Diamond said he hopes Council will reconsider the matter. He said he agrees there should be a limit, but feels it should be set much higher. Mr. Larry Hammond, 1358 Brandlin Drive, said that he plays the bagpipes and is concerned that the ordinance will criminalize this activity. Mr. Hammond said Charlottesville is a world class city because of the richness of diversity, and there should be more serious things for the police and courts to deal with. Mr. Hammond said he thinks limits are needed, perhaps during reasonable hours and certain days. Mr. Chris Brumfield, 2508 Eastham Drive, also a bagpipe player, apologized to rnerchants and residents, and said he does not intend to impede on their privacy. He said they have had a great response to their playing and have received very few complaints. Mr. Joan Fentorg 3705 Country Lane and business owner on the downtown mall, said she supports the ordinance. She said she would much prefer to just ask people to turn the music down, but they have been unwilling to. Ms. Fenton said she has been unable to conduct business with the level of music. Ms. Fenton said perhaps the distance measured should be increased, and feels it needs to be done in a way that is fair. Mr. Weldon Jones, 109 Robertson Avenue, said the ordinance may create a climate of fear and intolerance of street musicians. Ms. Jill Williams, 101 3~d St., S.E., said that her intention in supporting a noise ordinance is not to restrict street music, but feels there needs to be a balance. She said when she has asked musicians to turn the noise level down, their answer is always "there is no noise ordinance." Mr. Dave Montieth, 51 Shady Lane, a bagpiper, said he has only received one complaint. He said there are no volume controls on bagpipes. He said he only plays on the mall on weekends. He asked that he be told where and when he can play, but asked that he not be restricted outright. Mr. Oliver Kuttner, 108 2na Street, N.W., said people choose to live on the mall knowing that it is an entertainment center and said he feels it is a mistake to try to legislate everything. Mr. Kuttner said he would like to see common courtesy and appealed to the musicians not to be so loud and not to stay in the same place all the time. A resident of 110 E. Main Street for ten years, said there have been numerous occasions where people have not been courteous about noise levels, and noted that a residential base is needed for the mall to thrive. He said it is important that merchants and residents on the mall be respected. He said he thinks an ordinance is necessary and encouraged Council to put something into place. Mr. Oliver Kuttner suggested that the City use brooms instead of leaf blowers on the mall. As there were no further speakers, the public hearing was closed. Mr. Caravati noted that this discussion has been going on for three years and he would like to fmd a way for residents, merchants and musicians to co-exist. Mr. Caravati said that numerous complaints about noise levels have been received and he thinks some ground niles need to be set. Mr. Caravati asked Mr. Gouldman to respond to the comment made about the legality of the notice. Mr. Gouldman said that the ordinance was available to the public the same time it was available to Councilors and there is no publication requirement for the public