2007-10-15 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

8 Mr. Kruger said that the YMCA delayed the process by ten months because it wants to serve the underprivileged. Mr. Lynch said he thinks the YMCA’s response is pretty positive though there are a couple of issues he wants to see ironed out. The public hearing was opened. Mr. Paul White, 1801 Hydraulic Road, representing Gold’s Gym, said he is glad that the YMCA’s proposal will accommodate low income residents as that was his main concern. Mr. Downing Smith, 810 Locust Avenue, said that the proposal is technically a lease, but is basically a gift. He said there is no exhibit showing the location and no exhibit regarding use. He said it is too complicated getting the County involved. He said the question is does the City want to partner with the YMCA and have the facility in the park. He said if the City owns the facility it has control. He questioned the financial ability of the YMCA to take on this project, and said the City should require three years of audited financial statements. He said the YMCA also does not have the experience to build or operate such a facility. He noted that the stated purpose of the YMCA is to put Christian spirit into practice. He urged Council to vote against the proposal. Ms. Missy Cruz, 2402 Pendower Lane, Keswick, said that her child swims for the YMCA and there is a collaborative event taking place on Friday between the YMCA, City Parks and Recreation, the Boys and Girls Club and Covenant Elementary School at Smith Pool. She said the City needs to have pool space available so that events such as this can take place. Ms. Colette Hall, 101 Robertson Lane, said she had previously heard that the YMCA wanted to lease space in the park, but is now hearing that the YMCA also wants the City to contribute $1.25 million. She asked if we need the YMCA facility if we rebuild Smith pool. She said we are losing part of the park to the Meadowcreek Parkway and now we are losing more of it for a recreational facility. She said she previously heard that CHS students would have priority use of the YMCA lap lanes, but is now hearing that will have to be balanced with Albemarle County. Ms. Beth Elliott, 1640 Rio Hill, said that the YMCA should put in a very small warm water pool which would be good for seniors and those with disabilities. Mr. Peter Kleeman, 407 Hedge Street, said it is difficult to discern the benefits of the pool proposals. He said Council should look at the benefit streams and a time value approach to evaluate the alternatives. Mr. Kruger said that the facility would not be run with existing YMCA staff. He noted that the YMCA promotes Judea-Christian principles, not just Christian. Ms. Shelia Romalio said that she originally questioned if she wanted to be part of a male and Christian organization. She said the YMCA is all inclusive. She said she is now the developmental director for the YMCA. She said the YMCA will provide two years of audits. She asked Council to look at the big picture in a timely manner. As there were no further speakers at the meeting, the public hearing was th continued until the November 5 meeting. Ms. Hamilton said she believed it was clear during discussion in the summer that the City’s contribution would be land, not funding and that competitive swimming lanes would be included. She said she thinks the City and the YMCA are close together on some things, but not on others. She questioned whether the Smith proposal would be in competition with the YMCA and if the Smith facility could undermine the viability of the YMCA. She said she is hearing concerns from citizens about privatizing pools and parks operations. She said she is not bothered by the thought of the YMCA facility being located in the County. She said she will be weighing those issues.