2010-03-01 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

5 Mr. Norris asked what the rationale was behind limiting the noise to amplified, and Mr. Tolbert said Council was trying to regulate music, not conversation. Mr. O’Connell presented a summary of noise coming from Bel Rio. He noted that while the average was much lower, it was as high as 92.6 a few weeks ago. Mr. Norris asked how many total noise complaints there have been in Belmont and how many of those are from Bel Rio. Lieutenant Cheryl Sandridge of the Charlottesville Police Department said that 100% of the complaints were about Bel Rio. Responding to a question from Mr. O’Connell, Lieutenant Sandridge said that the noise meters used by the Police Department are calibrated before and after each use and certified for the court. She noted that they do not measure base, just noise. Mr. Norris asked if measures have been taken to work with Bel Rio to be a better neighbor, and if so, what was the response. Mr. Tolbert said staff has met with the owner of Bel Rio and sound proofing was suggested, but staff was told that they had already invested in the building and they would not be spending any more money. Mr. Jim Baldi, owner of Bel Rio, said $30,000 has been put into the building. He said he asked the neighborhood association to meet at Bel Rio to discuss possibilities, but they have not responded. Mr. Huja noted that the proposed ordinance is very limited in scope and will apply to a very limited area of the City. Mr. Norris asked if noise complaints have been received from Fontaine Avenue, and Mr. Tolbert said no. Ms. Szakos said ordinances are not punishment, but they give residents a tool and are not subjective. She said it is time for an ordinance in this neighborhood. She said she is a musician, but when there is a line between businesses and residents we need to find a balance. She said we have moved too far to one side. Dr. Brown said Council has been asked to give the neighborhood a chance to work this out themselves, but he is pessimistic about that happening. He said a compelling case has been made for how important music is to Charlottesville, and we should be careful not to take too quick a step in the wrong direction. He said he does not agree that this is the first step in the direction of a city-wide ordinance. He said this addresses a specific problem in a specific neighborhood. He said he is still concerned that 60 decibels is too low a standard and would rather err on having the decibel level being too high and adjust it later than have restaurants close. He said he would prefer to see the level set at 65 decibels. Ms. Edwards said this is an opportunity for Bel Rio to think about insulation. She said she would like to look at the complaints and readings in six months as well as their business. Ms. Szakos said she does not think 65 decibels would deal with complaints, and would agree to a level of 60 decibels. Mr. Huja said he thinks a decibel level of 60 would be a compromise on both sides. Mr. Norris said that with the average night at Bel Rio being 63 to 65 decibels, this ordinance would not clamp down on them, and he would agree with the 65 decibels. Dr. Brown made a motion to amend the ordinance to set a limit of 65 decibels after 11:00 p.m.